The core idea
Performance management connects agreed expectations, feedback, development and accountability. Armstrong and Taylor distinguish the broader practice from formal review systems and emphasise leadership in everyday work. A useful conversation considers results and how they were achieved, the conditions affecting performance and the support needed for the next period.
Source and attribution [1]Using it in practice
Agree a manageable set of outcomes, quality standards and behaviours appropriate to the role. Check understanding and available resources. Hold timely conversations using specific evidence, invite the employee’s account and distinguish controllable actions from external conditions. Agree a small number of next steps and review them. Formal capability or disciplinary action requires the relevant fair process and current legal guidance.
An example, not a reported case
Worked example · illustrative
A supervisor is criticised for slow incident closure. A discussion of actual cases shows that unclear escalation rights cause delay. The manager clarifies authority, provides practice on complex cases and agrees a review of quality and timeliness. Accountability remains, but the response addresses the mechanism rather than merely demanding a higher score.
What to watch for
Ratings can create an appearance of precision while reflecting different standards or opportunities. Forced comparisons may undermine cooperation. Coaching is not a substitute for addressing serious concerns, and a formal review should not be the first time an employee hears a problem.
Make the purpose of the meeting explicit
CIPD presents performance management as a continuing set of practices supported by regular discussion, rather than an annual form alone. Before a particular conversation, explain whether it concerns routine progress, development, recognition or a specific performance concern. Do not disguise a formal process as a friendly catch-up. Give the person a reasonable understanding of the issue and the opportunity to prepare. If pay or progression is also being discussed, be clear about which decisions are available today and which require another process. This makes it easier to discuss learning without implying that every admission of difficulty will determine a reward decision.
Describe the work before interpreting the person
Bring a small number of relevant examples and check their accuracy. Separate an observation from an inference: two reports were late is an observation; you do not care is an interpretation. Explain why the work matters and ask for the employee’s account before deciding the cause. Look at dependencies, competing instructions and resources as well as individual choices. A manager should be willing to correct their own understanding. Avoid building a case from selectively remembered failures while ignoring similar work completed well or obstacles that have already been raised.
Worked example: a useful opening and a better diagnosis
Original illustrative wording: “The last two handover reports reached the next shift after it started, so they had to begin without the incident summary. I want to understand what got in the way and agree a reliable approach. How did those shifts run from your perspective?” The employee explains that a required approval was unavailable. The manager checks that dependency before treating lateness as an individual capability problem. They agree an interim escalation route and a short review of the next few handovers. The example is a conversation aid, not a formal warning template or a substitute for investigating disputed facts.
Choose an objective that fits the complexity of the work
CIPD distinguishes straightforward outcome goals from complex work where learning or behavioural objectives may be more useful. An original example for a new analyst is to compare two methods, explain their limitations and obtain feedback on the recommendation before being judged only on speed. For established routine work, an agreed timeliness and quality standard may be appropriate. Check that the measure is within the employee’s influence and does not reward a shortcut that harms colleagues or customers. Where delivery is shared, identify the manager’s and team’s commitments alongside the individual objective.
Turn the discussion into a small, workable agreement
Write what will be done differently, what support or resources will be provided, who owns each action and when progress will be discussed. For example, the employee drafts the report earlier, the manager secures access to the required data, and both review a sample of completed work at the next check-in. Include how the employee can raise a blocker before that meeting. Ask them to explain the agreement in their own words and record any disagreement accurately. A signature or silence should not be treated as evidence that every point is accepted or that support has actually been delivered.
Handle emotion without losing clarity
AIHR’s member guide on difficult conversations highlights preparation, role clarity and follow-up. In an original performance application, a manager can acknowledge that the discussion is upsetting, offer a pause and return to the specific work issue when the person is ready. Listening does not require abandoning an appropriate standard. Equally, a standard does not justify humiliation, threats or an assumption about someone’s health. If new information changes the nature of the issue, pause to obtain appropriate HR advice. Do not improvise a disciplinary outcome during what was presented as a routine coaching conversation.
Recognise contribution and support development
Discuss effective work with the same specificity as a concern. Explain which contribution helped the team and ask what enabled it. Recognition can identify a useful practice to share, while checking that it is not sustained by hidden overwork. Invite the person to identify a capability they want to develop and connect it to an available opportunity. Do not make every development conversation conditional on promotion. Skilled individual contribution, mentoring and broader experience can all be worthwhile. Keep promises small enough to deliver, and return to them at the next discussion.
Review the manager’s commitments as well as the employee’s
At follow-up, compare the agreed work with current evidence and ask whether promised support arrived. If it did not, correct the plan rather than treating the original deadline as conclusive. Where progress is insufficient, distinguish an unrealistic plan, an unresolved obstacle and a continuing concern about performance. Explain the next step and use the relevant procedure if the matter becomes formal. This guide offers good-practice discussion methods; it does not replace current procedural requirements, individual adjustments or advice on a particular case. Use the linked discipline and grievance guide for the separate process context.
Take it into your next conversation
Three useful questions.
- Does the employee understand the purpose of this meeting?
- Which observations support the concern, and what could explain them?
- What is the manager promising to do?
Go to the evidence
Sources & attribution
Further reading: Michael Armstrong with Stephen Taylor (2023), Armstrong’s Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice, 16th edition, chapters 41–43. Edition & reading notes ↗
Further reading: Jo Owen (2021), The Leadership Skills Handbook: 100 essential skills you need to be a leader, 5th edition, PDF pp. 80, 82, 90, 92 and 122. Edition & reading notes ↗
[1] Armstrong & Taylor (2023), 16th edition, chapters 41–43 — reading notes ↗
[2] CIPD, Performance management: An introduction (29 January 2026); consulted 28 September 2026 ↗
[3] AIHR member resource, Managing Difficult Conversations (2023); consulted 28 September 2026 ↗
The core idea is an original summary of the cited work. Application notes, examples and sketches are our interpretations, not quotations or reproductions of the authors’ figures. Publisher records may require access to read the full original work.
Original ADM HR teaching guide with attributed background reading. Practical sections expanded on 28 September 2026 following the CIPD and AIHR reading listed in the sources. Worked examples, suggested review periods and decision aids are original editorial illustrations, not validated models or universal standards. Member resources are linked for further reading; their documents and templates are not reproduced here. The original overview review date is retained; this expansion is not a fresh legal review of every linked article.
Published 2026-09-25 · Reviewed 2026-09-25. Editorial approach