The core idea
Hersey and Blanchard developed situational leadership together, then pursued distinct versions. The competence-and-commitment language and directing, coaching, supporting and delegating labels used here describe Blanchard’s later SLII approach. Hersey’s Situational Leadership uses task-specific performance readiness and related terminology. In SLII, directing combines high direction with lower support, coaching combines both at high levels, supporting reduces direction while retaining support, and delegating reduces both. These are responses to a particular goal or task, not permanent labels for employees.
Source and attribution [1]Using it in practice
Agree the task and what competent performance looks like. Ask about relevant experience, confidence and motivation rather than inferring them from tenure. Decide what instructions, practice, feedback and check-ins would help. Review the agreement as performance develops or the work changes. HR can train managers to have this conversation without presenting a four-box classification as a precise scientific diagnosis.
An example, not a reported case
Worked example · illustrative
An experienced security officer becomes a first-time scheduler. Their operational knowledge is strong, but they have not used the planning system. The manager provides clear steps and checks the first schedules, while explaining why the constraints matter. As the officer gains fluency, reviews focus on judgement in unusual cases. The manager delegates routine scheduling within agreed limits, while remaining available. Expertise in one part of the job is not treated as automatic competence in every new responsibility.
What to watch for
Do not combine different versions’ labels and developmental categories as if they were identical. A lack of resources, unclear authority or an inaccessible system can resemble a capability problem. Lower supportive behaviour in a model does not mean disrespect or neglect. Empirical support and practical usefulness should be considered separately; the framework is a conversation aid, not a guarantee that a particular style will cause success.
Directing and coaching
Use clear direction when a task needs instruction: demonstrate, explain the standard and check understanding. Coaching in this framework adds substantial supportive discussion to substantial direction. It is not identical to non-directive professional coaching. Ask what is confusing and create a safe opportunity to practise before expecting independent delivery.
Supporting and delegating
Supporting can involve listening, shared problem-solving and encouragement when the person can perform the work but benefits from discussion. Delegating should specify the result, authority limits and when to reconnect. It does not mean disappearing. An agreed checkpoint protects autonomy better than unpredictable intervention after every decision.
Review task-specific evidence
A person may need detailed instruction for one responsibility and broad autonomy for another. Keep the assessment tied to examples of work. Invite the person to disagree with your interpretation. If their confidence falls, investigate changed demands or feedback before assuming a stable personal deficit.
A development conversation
Ask: what outcome are we aiming for, what can you already do, what feels uncertain and what support would be useful? Agree a small next step and a review date. Record the agreement in ordinary language. Use formal branded tools only through an authorised route; this guide does not reproduce their questionnaires.
Assess readiness for the specific task
An experienced employee can be new to a particular system, and a new starter may already be proficient in part of the role. Discuss competence and confidence for the task in question rather than assigning the person a permanent development level. Use evidence from practice and ask what support they find useful. Keep the assessment collaborative; a manager's assumption that someone lacks commitment can conceal unclear expectations, missing resources or disagreement about the task.
Agree the supervision arrangement openly
State the outcome, level of instruction, decision freedom, check-in frequency and escalation points. For an unfamiliar safety-critical task, close guidance may be appropriate; for a demonstrated routine task, repeated approval may add little value. Explain that the arrangement can change with evidence. Do not move between intense control and sudden withdrawal without discussion, because the employee may experience inconsistency rather than adaptive leadership.
Use a development example
Imagine a capable supervisor learning a new rostering system. Initially, they may need a worked demonstration and supervised practice. As accuracy improves, the manager can ask them to explain their decisions and handle routine cases independently, while retaining a route for exceptions. The change in approach follows demonstrated capability, not simply elapsed time. Check confidence separately: someone may perform well but still need reassurance, or feel confident before their accuracy is reliable.
Distinguish the model from a validated diagnosis
Hersey and Blanchard's original approach and later variants use different terminology and instruments; do not combine them as though they are identical. The simplified guide supports a practical conversation, not a proprietary assessment. Leadership outcomes also depend on workload, relationships and organisational constraints. If adapting the style does not help, examine those factors rather than repeatedly relabelling the employee's development level.
Assess readiness for the task, not the person in general
An experienced employee may need clear direction on a new system while working independently in familiar duties. Discuss the specific task, observe relevant performance and ask about confidence, understanding and obstacles. Avoid treating reluctance as low commitment before checking whether the instruction is unclear or the risk is real. The original Hersey–Blanchard approach and later branded variants use different terminology; do not mix their scales as if they were one validated diagnostic.
Make changes in supervision explicit
Agree what the employee can decide, which checks are required and what would justify less or more support. For a new incident-reporting task, demonstrate a good report, practise together, then review a small sample before reducing oversight. Owen’s delegation guidance complements this application: support should build capability without continuous interference. Reassess when the task changes. A leader who increases supervision after an unexplained setback can appear arbitrary; explain the evidence and involve the employee in the next step.
Take it into your next conversation
Three useful questions.
- What does this particular situation need from the leader?
- How will colleagues experience the approach, including those with less influence?
- What evidence would tell us to continue, adjust or stop?
Related terms
Go to the evidence
Sources & attribution
Further reading: Jo Owen (2021), The Leadership Skills Handbook: 100 essential skills you need to be a leader, 5th edition, PDF pp. 80, 82, 90, 92 and 122. Edition & reading notes ↗
[1] Blanchard: a situational approach to effective leadership ↗
[2] Center for Leadership Studies: Hersey’s Situational Leadership ↗
The core idea is an original summary of the cited work. Application notes, examples and sketches are our interpretations, not quotations or reproductions of the authors’ figures. Publisher records may require access to read the full original work.
Application guidance expanded on 26 September 2026. These practical suggestions and invented examples are editorial explanations; further-reading sources are not the original authors of the historical models unless expressly identified. Original overview review dates are retained.
Published 2026-09-20 · Reviewed 2026-09-22. Editorial approach