← HR strategy

HRM practice

Competency frameworks: describe useful behaviour clearly

Build a small, observable framework that supports development and fairer decisions rather than vague personality judgements.

ADM HR; reading: Armstrong & Taylor · 2023 · Original editorial explanation
Competency frameworks: describe useful behaviour clearly — simplified model sketchRole evidence · Clear behaviours · Shared judgement · Development. Editorial interpretation, after ADM HR; reading: Armstrong & Taylor (2023).Roleevidence01Clearbehaviours02Sharedjudgement03Development04ADM HR · ORIGINAL INTERPRETATIONADM HR; reading: Armstrong & Taylor · 2023
Original ADM HR application sketch. Read the explanation for assumptions and limitations. Download SVG ↗

The core idea

Competency frameworks describe the capabilities or behaviours expected for effective work. Terminology varies: some writers distinguish behavioural competency from task-based competence, but organisations do not use the words consistently. Armstrong and Taylor discuss frameworks as a way of connecting people processes. Their value depends on clear definitions and credible evidence from the work.

Source and attribution [1]

Using it in practice

Start with a few important roles and gather examples of effective and ineffective performance. Translate these into observable actions, keeping context and level of responsibility explicit. Test the wording with role holders and managers. Pilot the framework in development conversations before using it for high-stakes decisions. Explain how evidence will be gathered and how disagreements can be reviewed.

An example, not a reported case

Worked example · illustrative

A supervisor framework replaces “strong presence” with examples such as explaining priorities, checking understanding and escalating safety concerns promptly. Assessors discuss evidence from several situations rather than judging confidence in one interview. Employees can see what to practise and what a more demanding role would require.

What to watch for

A framework can encode the preferences of its designers. Traits such as polish or cultural fit may reward similarity rather than effectiveness. Behaviour also depends on resources, opportunity and team conditions. Do not infer a fixed personal deficit from one incident.

Separate requirements from preferences

Ask whether each criterion is necessary to the work and how someone could demonstrate it in different ways. Avoid descriptions that simply resemble current high-status employees. Review whether part-time staff or people at quieter sites have equivalent opportunities to provide evidence.

Use levels carefully

Higher levels should describe increased complexity, scope or independence, not increasingly flattering adjectives. Keep the framework short enough for a manager and employee to use in a real conversation. Provide examples without making them an exhaustive checklist.

Calibrate and improve

Ask assessors to rate the same sample evidence and explain their judgement. Investigate disagreement before assuming an average score is accurate. Revise ambiguous descriptors and check for patterns of inconsistent application across groups and locations.

Translate an abstract capability into observable work

Influence is too broad to assess reliably without context. In an HR partnering role it might involve understanding stakeholders’ concerns, presenting evidence and negotiating a workable agreement. Define examples at the level of responsibility required, with room for different effective styles. The CEB model is a historical reference for HRBP capability areas; it should not be copied wholesale into a current assessment or treated as a validated test for your particular organisation.

Separate capability from opportunity to demonstrate it

Someone may receive a low rating because they have not been assigned relevant work. Ask what evidence is available and which opportunities were accessible before interpreting absence of evidence as low ability. Avoid equating confidence, accent or similarity to current leaders with competence. Use more than one example and calibrate assessors against the same requirements. Employees should understand the framework and how they can develop, challenge inaccuracies or provide additional evidence.

Keep the framework small enough to use

Choose capabilities that materially affect performance in the role rather than producing a long list of desirable attributes. Pilot the descriptions in development conversations and examine where managers disagree. Revise unclear language and remove duplication. A development use may tolerate exploratory discussion, while selection or pay decisions need stronger consistency and governance. Review the framework when work changes; retaining an obsolete competency because it is already in the system can make assessment look precise while missing what now matters.

Connect the framework to movement, not just ratings

AIHR connects a skills-based organisation with workforce decisions, development and internal mobility. An operational framework needs a maintained vocabulary, evidence and opportunities to use skills. A large catalogue without ownership can create apparent precision while different managers use the same label differently. Start with a bounded decision and test the descriptions before applying them to consequential outcomes.

Original ADM exercise: three levels of case analysis

For an illustrative HR team, describe developing capability as constructing a reliable chronology with supervision; independent capability as testing conflicting accounts and identifying when to escalate; and broader capability as improving the investigation approach across teams. These are local examples, not a universal professional standard. Ask two assessors to review anonymised sample work and explain their evidence. Mark unavailable evidence as unknown rather than automatically low. Offer a supervised assignment to fill a genuine evidence gap. Revisit the descriptors when responsibilities change and preserve the version used for each assessment.

Take it into your next conversation

Three useful questions.

  1. Can we observe this requirement in the work?
  2. Could someone demonstrate it in more than one way?
  3. What support would enable improvement?

Related terms

Go to the evidence

Sources & attribution

Further reading: Michael Armstrong with Stephen Taylor (2023), Armstrong’s Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice, 16th edition, chapters 16, 72. Edition & reading notes ↗

Further reading: CEB Corporate Leadership Council (2014), HR Business Partner Competency Model: Understanding Critical Skills and Knowledge for Effective HR Delivery, Historical competency model, PDF pp. 6–8. Edition & reading notes ↗

[1] Armstrong & Taylor (2023), 16th edition, chapters 16, 72 — reading notes ↗

[2] AIHR: building a skills-based organisation ↗

The core idea is an original summary of the cited work. Application notes, examples and sketches are our interpretations, not quotations or reproductions of the authors’ figures. Publisher records may require access to read the full original work.

Original teaching guide informed by the cited handbook chapters. The four-step sketch is an ADM HR application aid, not a named Armstrong model. Examples are invented. The 2023 book is not used to establish current employment law. Application guidance expanded on 26 September 2026. These practical suggestions and invented examples are editorial explanations; further-reading sources are not the original authors of the historical models unless expressly identified. Original overview review dates are retained. Targeted editorial update on 15 October 2026. New application exercises are original ADM HR illustrations. Current public sources were checked; this update does not claim a fresh review of member-only material.

Published 2026-09-25 · Reviewed 2026-10-15. Editorial approach

Keep exploring

A little more context.

Clarity, challenge & feedback02

Locke & Latham’s goal-setting theory

Design goals that focus attention without encouraging shortcuts or pretending complex learning is a simple target.

Edwin A. Locke4 min