Specialist field guide / 1 October 2026
The route through this subject
Start with the overview, then open each decision below. These are learning prompts; the detailed legal qualifications remain essential.
- 01Check eligibility↓
- 02Identify the real reason↓
- 03Test evidence and fairness↓
- 04Check other rights↓
- 05Decide, explain, appeal
Decision tree
1Has a dismissal occurred or been proposed?
Identify the statutory and contractual routes separately.
Consider detriment, discrimination, grievance or contractual issues instead.
2Is a protected reason or discrimination alleged?
Analyse its specific legal test; short service is not a universal defence.
Still document why the stated reason is the genuine principal reason.
3Can the employer establish a potentially fair reason?
Assess fair process, alternatives and reasonable response under section 98(4).
Do not assume a contractual right to terminate makes dismissal fair.
4Is dismissal without notice proposed?
Separately assess actual repudiatory breach and contractual notice liability.
Calculate notice and other sums, then communicate the outcome and appeal.
Case law: principle and limits
British Home Stores v Burchell [1978] IRLR 379 ↗
Genuine belief, reasonable grounds and reasonable investigation in misconduct cases. Do not treat it as proof that the employee committed the act.
Sainsbury’s Supermarkets v Hitt [2002] EWCA Civ 1588 ↗
The reasonable-responses approach extends to the investigation. Avoid substituting the tribunal’s preferred investigation for the employer’s reasonable one.
Polkey v AE Dayton Services [1987] UKHL 8 ↗
A likely identical outcome does not cure procedural unfairness; the chance of a fair dismissal can affect compensation.
Western Excavating v Sharp [1978] ICR 221 ↗
Constructive dismissal depends on contractual breach, not simply unreasonable treatment; resignation and affirmation require careful analysis.
Royal Mail v Jhuti [2019] UKSC 55 ↗
A concealed retaliatory reason can be attributed to the employer in the circumstances identified by the Court. Investigate who shaped the decision-maker’s evidence.
Editable Word tools
Original ADM HR worksheets. Complete and adapt them; use the official forms for tribunal filings.
Browse the template library →The legal position
Employment Rights Act 1996 section 98 identifies potentially fair reasons: capability or qualifications, conduct, redundancy, statutory restriction and some other substantial reason (SOSR). The employer must establish the reason or principal reason; the tribunal then considers reasonableness under section 98(4). A potentially fair reason is not a safe harbour. Contractual notice, discrimination, protected disclosures and other automatically unfair grounds must be examined separately.
Source and attribution [1]Using it in practice
Start with the real concern and preserve contemporaneous evidence. Use a record that separates allegations, established facts, disputed facts, applicable legal tests, the employee’s explanation, alternatives and reasons for the outcome. Decision-makers should be able to explain why contrary evidence did not change their conclusion. Do not retrofit a new rationale after the decision or assume an appeal can cure every earlier defect.
An example, not a reported case
Worked example · illustrative
Illustration: a supervisor is accused of altering a patrol record. The investigator obtains the system audit and interviews the supervisor, who identifies a clock-synchronisation fault. The decision-maker tests that explanation before deciding whether dishonesty, capability or no misconduct is established. “Trust has broken down” is not used to avoid the unresolved factual issue. If misconduct is found, consistency, mitigation and proportionate sanction remain separate questions.
What to watch for
Cases provide principles, not a checklist that guarantees a win. Apply the current statute and later authority to the actual facts. A disciplinary policy’s gross-misconduct label does not itself prove a repudiatory breach or justify an unfair dismissal. Protected-reason, disability and contractual claims may coexist.
1. Eligibility, dismissal and the actual reason
Check employee status, territorial scope, continuous service and whether a dismissal occurred, including expiry/non-renewal of a fixed-term contract or qualifying constructive dismissal. As at 1 October 2026, ordinary unfair dismissal generally requires two years’ service. Government guidance announces a six-month threshold and removal of the compensatory-award cap from 1 January 2027; do not apply those future changes to a current dismissal without checking commencement and transition. Many automatically unfair and discrimination claims do not require two years. A probation clause does not remove statutory rights.
2. Conduct: reasonable belief, grounds and investigation
Burchell asks whether the employer genuinely believed misconduct occurred, had reasonable grounds and carried out as much investigation as was reasonable. Read the case through the current statutory burden: the employer establishes the reason, while section 98(4) fairness is not simply a reverse burden of proof. Hitt confirms the range-of-reasonable-responses approach applies to investigation too. The tribunal is not deciding whether it would have dismissed or conducting a criminal trial. Practice: test exculpatory explanations, identify missing evidence and record why further enquiries were or were not proportionate.
3. Capability and qualifications
For poor performance, identify the required standard, evidence of the gap, support and opportunity to improve, relevant warnings and alternatives. For ill-health capability, consider up-to-date medical evidence, consultation, prognosis and operational effects, alongside Equality Act duties. Capability is not automatically blameworthy conduct. Practice: distinguish an inability to perform from a refusal, a training gap or an inaccessible process. Agree review measures the employee can understand and avoid moving targets. A medical report informs the decision; it does not make the legal judgement for the employer.
4. Redundancy and statutory restriction
A genuine redundancy still requires a fair approach to consultation, selection and alternatives. Use the specialist redundancy guide for counting and notification duties. A statutory restriction concerns continued employment contravening a legal requirement; distinguish a verified legal bar from an administrative delay or an assumption about documents. Practice: identify the precise rule, evidence and possible lawful alternatives. If permission or professional registration is disputed, obtain specialist advice and give the employee a reasonable opportunity to address the evidence before concluding that dismissal is necessary.
5. Some other substantial reason
SOSR is fact-sensitive and must be substantial enough to justify dismissal of an employee in that position. Potential examples include a serious third-party pressure situation or a genuine business reorganisation, but the label proves nothing. Examine the underlying evidence, representations, alternatives and reasonableness. Practice: where a client asks for someone’s removal, test the complaint, contractual position and redeployment options rather than treating the request as an instruction to dismiss. Do not use SOSR to conceal misconduct allegations, whistleblowing retaliation or discriminatory customer preferences.
6. Automatically unfair and discriminatory reasons
Screen for pregnancy/family leave, protected disclosures, health-and-safety activity, trade-union activity, assertion of statutory rights and other protected grounds. Each cause of action has its own elements and sometimes its own service conditions. Jhuti illustrates why a hidden retaliatory reason may matter even where the final decision-maker was deceived. Practice: review the chronology of protected acts and management responses, including who supplied the evidence. Discrimination claims require the applicable Equality Act analysis; “within the range of reasonable responses” is not a complete defence to them.
7. Wrongful and summary dismissal
Wrongful dismissal concerns breach of contract, commonly failure to give notice or pay in lieu where no right to dismiss summarily exists. It does not generally require two years’ service. A summary dismissal is dismissal without notice; it is a method of termination, not a separate potentially fair statutory reason. In a wrongful-dismissal claim, the tribunal/court may need to decide whether conduct actually justified summary termination, unlike the reasonable-belief focus of misconduct unfair dismissal. Practice: assess notice entitlement separately from sanction and document the contractual basis.
8. Constructive dismissal
Constructive dismissal usually involves resignation in response to the employer’s fundamental contractual breach, without affirmation. Western Excavating distinguishes the contractual test from mere unreasonable behaviour. A series of acts and a final straw can require careful analysis. Practice: when an employee alleges a serious breach, investigate and respond promptly rather than assuming a resignation ends all risk. Employees should obtain advice before resigning: the timing, reason and subsequent conduct can determine the claim, and a grievance does not pause tribunal limitation.
9. Procedure, accompaniment and appeal
For applicable disciplinary/grievance cases, follow the Acas Code: investigate, explain the concern and evidence, allow a response at a fair hearing, consider the decision and offer appeal. The statutory right to an eligible companion applies to qualifying disciplinary and grievance hearings; it is not a universal right at every investigatory meeting. Make reasonable adjustments where required. Unreasonable Code failures can change relevant awards by up to 25%. The Code excludes redundancy and fixed-term expiry non-renewal; do not apply the uplift automatically to every dismissal.
10. Fairness and compensation are separate
Polkey establishes that an unfair procedure is not made fair merely because the employer says the result would have been the same. Compensation may nevertheless be reduced to reflect the chance or timing of a fair dismissal. Separate that assessment from contributory conduct and other remedy issues. Practice: preserve evidence about alternatives and likely outcomes, but first ask whether the process was fair when conducted. A speculative assertion that “nothing would have changed” is not an adequate decision record.
11. Build a tribunal-ready record without writing for litigation
Keep the original evidence, the employee’s explanation, the findings and the reasons for the chosen outcome. Identify who made each decision and whether they had authority. Distinguish legal advice from ordinary management records; copying a lawyer into an email does not automatically make it privileged. Practice: use plain language, correct factual errors openly and retain earlier versions. An honest record of uncertainty and how it was resolved is more useful than a polished retrospective narrative.
Take it into your next conversation
Three useful questions.
- What is the real reason for dismissal?
- Could a separate protected right apply?
- Have contractual and statutory questions both been checked?
Related terms
Go to the evidence
Sources & attribution
Further reading: Daniel Barnett (2024), SOSR Dismissals, 2024 publication, Chapter 9; PDF pp. 70–71. Edition & reading notes ↗
[1] Employment Rights Act 1996, section 98 ↗
[2] GOV.UK: eligibility and January 2027 change ↗
[3] Government: unfair-dismissal reform dates ↗
[4] Acas disciplinary and grievance Code ↗
[6] Hitt judgment ↗
[8] Western Excavating judgment ↗
[9] Royal Mail v Jhuti, Supreme Court ↗
Official guidance supports the legal overview. Application notes and examples are original editorial material, not individual legal advice. Check the linked source for changes and the full qualifications.
Original ADM HR practical guide, reviewed against the linked official guidance, legislation and judgments on 1 October 2026. Examples and worksheets are editorial illustrations. Great Britain unless stated; Northern Ireland has a separate framework. Use case-specific advice for live decisions and limitation dates.
Published 2026-09-20 · Reviewed 2026-10-01. Editorial approach