Specialist field guide / 1 October 2026
The route through this subject
Start with the overview, then open each decision below. These are learning prompts; the detailed legal qualifications remain essential.
- 01Define the proposal↓
- 02Count and notify↓
- 03Consult and assess↓
- 04Explore vacancies↓
- 05Decide and allow appeal
Decision tree
1Is there a genuine redundancy situation?
Document it and assess the proposed process.
Use the correct route for the actual issue; do not relabel a conduct case.
220+ proposed at one establishment within 90 days?
Check collective representation, 30/45-day minimums and HR1 before notices.
Use meaningful individual consultation; check policy and connected proposals.
3Is suitable alternative work available?
Assess suitability, priority rights and the statutory trial before dismissal.
Record the search and keep it under review during the process.
4Have representations been genuinely considered?
Make and explain an individual decision, payments and appeal route.
Pause final decisions and resolve the outstanding consultation issues.
Editable Word tools
Original ADM HR worksheets. Complete and adapt them; use the official forms for tribunal filings.
Browse the template library →The legal position
Redundancy is a potentially fair reason for dismissal, not a conclusion that dismissal is fair. Employment Rights Act 1996 section 139 covers business or workplace closure and a reduced requirement for employees to do work of a particular kind. The collective-consultation definition is broader: dismissals for reasons not related to the individual can count. Establish the real proposal, the applicable definition and the employees affected before selecting a process.
Source and attribution [1]Using it in practice
Use two connected records: a proposal-level record for the business case, alternatives and collective duties, and an individual record for selection evidence, representations, vacancies, payments and appeal. Explain what remains open to change. A process that begins with a final list of names and uses meetings only to explain it is difficult to reconcile with meaningful consultation.
An example, not a reported case
Worked example · illustrative
Illustration: a service business proposes 24 role reductions at one establishment over eight weeks. It plans collective consultation and HR1 notification, while also consulting individuals. Staff identify an unfilled contract mobilisation role; HR checks suitability and priority rights before advertising it. A scoring challenge reveals inconsistent evidence periods. Scores are corrected and the proposal changes. The decision record shows those changes rather than merely listing meetings held.
What to watch for
Do not split connected proposals to avoid counting duties. Establishment, proposed dismissals, fixed-term contracts and overlapping projects need careful assessment. The checklist is a teaching aid, not a declaration that a particular redundancy is lawful.
1. Show the genuine business requirement
Legal test: connect the proposed dismissal to the statutory redundancy situation, then assess fairness separately. A reduction in roles does not necessarily mean all work disappears; redistribution may still involve a diminished requirement for employees. Practice: compare the present and proposed work, required capabilities, savings assumptions and service risks. Distinguish role design from an attempt to remove someone for performance or conduct. Keep dated versions of the proposal so consultation changes are visible.
2. Count proposed dismissals before announcing the timetable
The current collective trigger is generally 20 or more proposed redundancies at one establishment within 90 days. For 20–99, consultation must begin in good time and at least 30 days before the first dismissal takes effect; for 100 or more, at least 45 days. Consult the recognised union or properly elected representatives about avoiding dismissals, reducing numbers and mitigating consequences, with a view to agreement. Individual consultation remains necessary for fairness. Organisation-wide threshold reform is a separate future measure; do not present it as the current counting rule.
3. HR1 is separate from consultation
Notify the Redundancy Payments Service using the current official HR1 route, meeting the applicable 30/45-day lead time and notifying before individual dismissal notices are issued. Give representatives a copy as required. A completed HR1 does not establish that consultation was adequate. Failure to notify can be a criminal matter; obtain urgent advice if the timetable is already compromised. Practice: keep the submitted form, acknowledgement, version history and confirmation of the numbers, sites and proposed dates used.
4. Below 20 does not mean no fair process
There is no fixed statutory minimum individual-consultation period for a smaller redundancy exercise. Allow a genuine chance to understand the proposal, challenge selection and suggest alternatives before deciding. Policy or contractual requirements may add duties. Practice: use an at-risk explanation, a first consultation meeting, a reasonable opportunity to provide information and a reasoned response. These are a practical sequence rather than a mandatory number of meetings. Accessible participation and an accurate record matter more than the label placed on each meeting.
5. Pools and criteria must be defensible
Consider interchangeable roles, skills, locations and the work that will remain when choosing the pool. Explain a narrow pool rather than treating it as self-evident. Criteria should be relevant, capable of consistent application and supported by evidence. Review absence, flexibility and performance measures for disability, pregnancy, family-leave and other discrimination risks. Practice: agree definitions and evidence periods before scoring; moderate inconsistent ratings; disclose enough information for a meaningful challenge while protecting other employees’ personal information. Do not disguise subjective preferences as objective numbers.
6. Consult on alternatives and respond to them
Possible options include recruitment restraint, voluntary measures, redeployment, training for available roles or a different operating design. None automatically solves the problem. For each suggestion, record the likely effect, cost, time, operational constraint and decision. Explain why it was accepted or rejected. Practice: maintain an alternatives log with an owner and response date. If new work emerges after the first meeting, assess it rather than relying on a closed vacancy list. Consultation must remain capable of changing the outcome.
7. Suitable alternatives and priority rights
Check available suitable alternative work, including the terms, skills, status, location and individual circumstances. Where statutory pregnancy/family-leave redundancy protection applies, an available suitable vacancy must be offered with the required priority rather than merely inviting an application. Some protected periods extend to 18 months after birth or placement, subject to the relevant leave rules. This is not immunity from a genuine redundancy. The usual statutory alternative-employment trial is four weeks; agreed retraining extensions have conditions. Suitability and whether refusal is unreasonable are distinct questions.
8. Notice and statutory redundancy payments
Eligible employees generally need two years’ continuous service for statutory redundancy pay. The formula uses completed years: half a week for each year below age 22, one week for each year aged 22–40 and one-and-a-half weeks for each year aged 41 or over, subject to 20 years and the statutory weekly limit. From 6 April 2026 the weekly cap is £751 and maximum statutory payment £22,530. Check the relevant date, age during each service year and any enhanced scheme. Notice, outstanding wages and holiday are separate calculations; do not assume all termination payments receive the same tax treatment.
9. Outcome and appeal
A written outcome should explain the reason, effective date, notice arrangements, payment breakdown, alternatives considered and appeal route. An appeal can examine factual errors, pool/criteria concerns, procedural defects and overlooked vacancies. Use an impartial reviewer where practicable and explain their decision. Practice: agree how a successful appeal will be implemented rather than offering a merely symbolic review. Keep job-search support and wellbeing contact separate from pressure to accept a settlement or waive rights.
10. Compensation and reform dates
From 6 April 2026, the maximum collective-consultation protective award increased to 180 days’ pay. It is distinct from statutory redundancy pay and from unfair-dismissal compensation; not every unsuccessful process results in the maximum. Insolvency recovery limits are another separate question. Check the tribunal deadlines guide for the October 2026 limitation transition. The ordinary unfair-dismissal service requirement remains generally two years until the announced January 2027 change; discrimination and many automatically unfair claims have different eligibility rules.
11. Aftercare and organisational learning
Review whether remaining work is deliverable, whether knowledge was handed over and whether the savings assumptions were realistic. Track appeals, redeployment outcomes and unresolved payroll issues without exposing individual cases. Practice: ask remaining teams what work has become unsafe or unmanageable and assign action owners. A redundancy project is not complete because the dismissal letters were sent. Keep an auditable retention schedule for the records, with access limited to those who need them.
Take it into your next conversation
Three useful questions.
- Have related proposals been considered together?
- Can consultation still change the proposal?
- Are individual and collective duties both covered?
Related terms
Go to the evidence
Sources & attribution
[1] Employment Rights Act 1996, section 139 ↗
[2] GOV.UK: collective consultation ↗
[3] GOV.UK: HR1 notification guidance ↗
[4] Acas: statutory redundancy pay ↗
[5] Acas: pregnancy and new-parent redundancy protection ↗
[6] GOV.UK: suitable alternative employment ↗
[7] Acas: failure to consult and protective awards ↗
[8] TULRCA 1992, section 188 ↗
Official guidance supports the legal overview. Application notes and examples are original editorial material, not individual legal advice. Check the linked source for changes and the full qualifications.
Original ADM HR practical guide, reviewed against the linked official guidance, legislation and judgments on 1 October 2026. Examples and worksheets are editorial illustrations. Great Britain unless stated; Northern Ireland has a separate framework. Use case-specific advice for live decisions and limitation dates.
Published 2026-09-20 · Reviewed 2026-10-01. Editorial approach